Back in 2005, The Cincinnati Bengals surprised everyone by going 11-5 and winning the AFC North. They were led by first year starter Carson Palmer who was heading into his third year with the Bengals. Wide receivers Chad Johnson, T.J. Houshmandzadeh and Chris Henry all had breakout years. Rudi Johnson established himself as a premier running back. Their defense gave up a ton of yards but their explosive offense could make up for it. Does this sound familiar? It should because the 2007 Browns were the mirror image of the 2005 Bengals. The Bengals dropped to 8-8 the following season and finished the ’07 season 7-9. But before I get into wins and losses, here are some things about the Browns that I know are good, some things I know are bad and some things I don’t have a f’n clue about.
The Offense
The Good News
The Browns have an offense line that would rather trade places with Marsellus Wallace in Zed’s basement than allow a sack. They only allowed 19 sacks last year compared to the 54 allowed in ’06. The left side of the line is especially good with Steinbach and Thomas serving up more pancakes than Prince. The right side with Shaffer and Hadnot is not as talented but I’d rather have the right side weaker than the left. The left side protects Anderson’s blindside so he doesn’t have to worry about being buried next to Tim Couch’s corpse.
Opposing secondary’s are going to be gassed early and often with the addition of Dante Stallworth. He is lighting fast and will be lined up opposite of Braylon Edwards for the most part. Defenses are going to have a Sophie’s Choice on their hands because they can’t double team both Stallworth and Edwards. If they do it means one-on-one linebacker coverage for Joe Jurevicius and/or Kellen Winslow. You can cover Jurevicius with a linebacker because he runs as fast as Forest Gump with knee braces. But linebackers will still have to cover him soft because Jurevicius hits his routes better than any receiver on the team. And defenses learned last year that covering Winslow one-on-one with a linebacker doesn’t really work. Winslow doesn’t drop passes and turns up field like defenders are trying to stop him from scoring crystal meth.
I also really like the way Jamal Lewis looks right now. He is at least a step quicker than he was last year. Also because of the Browns’ receivers, defenses can’t bank on putting eight guys in the box on third and three. And they can’t stack the line anymore on first and second down because the Browns have a QB who can pass the ball to someone that can actually catch. Instead of like when the QB was too busy getting sacked and the receivers swatted down balls like CBs. He’s also going to get a lot of help on his way to 1500 yards from Jason Wright and Jerome Harrison. The reason why the Browns’ running game didn’t work in the past was because they had no relief. The “every down back” was literally the every down back. Whoever it was would just get abused like Tina Turner. Not to mention the fact that runs to the left will result in at least three yards a carry with Steinbach and Thomas leading the way.
The Bad News Browns
Injuries are as common to the Browns as herpes outbreaks are to Paris Hilton. Rookie tight end Martin Rucker is going to be out 4-6 weeks. Jurevicius, Edwards, Winslow, Steve Heiden and fullback Lawrence Vickers are a little banged up right now too. I’m not really worried about Winslow because he would play through leukemia. Edwards’ injury doesn’t seem to be much of anything.
But I am worried about Jurevicius, Heiden and Vickers. Jurevicius can not be out of the lineup come opening day. The offense will not work with Travis Wilson as the third receiver. With the injury to Martin Rucker, Heiden has to be in the lineup as well because Winslow can’t run block and is involved too much in the passing game to be wasted as a pass blocker.
And Vickers blocks harder upfront than the fat chick at the bar with her hot friends. Not having him in the lineup would be a bigger blow to the Browns than not having Jurevicius, Heiden and Edwards healthy. Little things the Browns did well last year like running in between the tackles, screens and play action will be non existent.
The Ifs, Ands, or Buts
I don’t know what to make of Derek Anderson. His TD to INT ratio last year was 29/19 but 10 of his interceptions came in the last seven weeks of the season. In his first seven games as the starter he averaged 275 yards and 2.3 TDs a game. In his last seven games he averaged 222 yards and 1.3 TDs. So either defenses started to figure out his throwing patterns or he’s not a finisher. But then again he looked good in the preseason opener verses the Jets. So as of right now, how he will perform this year is a toss-up like Michael Ian Black’s sexuality. Thankfully, Brady Quinn is the number two and not Ken Dorsey.
Braylon Edwards is another if, and, or but. He is a phenomenal receiver…if the ball is thrown no where near him. Last year it seemed like any ball thrown dead on to him he dropped it. But a ball thrown towards Big Dawg was a guaranteed catch. This makes third and five yards or longer a little more difficult. Anderson can’t count on Edwards to make the play every time and has to rely on Winslow. Defenses should quickly pick up on this and will force Winslow to go inside over the middle. Winslow is the toughest player in the NFL and catches nearly every ball but constantly getting cracked coming across the middle isn’t going to be good for his longevity.
Staying healthy isn’t Dante Stallworth’s forte. He has only played every game in three out of his six seasons. If he gets hurt and misses five or six games, the Browns will miss the playoffs. Their offense is designed for legitimate NFL starters not arena league backups. That is why they went out and got Stallworth instead of just saying “F it” will make due with Travis Wilson. Losing Stallworth for five or six games, for this season, would be worse than having to listen to Tim McCarver roast Joe Buck.
The Defense
The Good News
“Big” Ted Washington’s corpse finally decomposed and now the Browns got two D-linemen that can actually play in Corey Williams and Shaun Rogers. The good news is that Washington died and is no longer apart of the Browns. The better news is that he didn’t want to go alone so he took Todd Grantham and his prevent defense with him. The Browns’ defense last year was God awful thanks mostly to Grantham. I can’t count how many times I wanted to vomit on third downs last year. I knew Washington wasn’t going to do anything except for have a heart attack while Grantham had the defense lineup in a dime on third and two. Thankfully things will be different this year.
Corey Williams has had back to back 7 sacks and 35 tackles seasons and last year Shaun Rogers had his best year since 2004 with 39 tackles and 7 sacks. Last year Ted Washington and his obese partner Orpheus Roye combined for 43 tackles and a whopping 0 sacks. Now the Browns have Williams, Rogers and Robaire Smith’s 56 tackles and 4 sacks upfront in the 3-4. Figure in the linebacker core of Willie McGinest/Antwon Peek, Andre Davis, D’Qwell Jackson’s 101 tackles and Kamerlon Wimbley; all of a sudden the Browns can…dare I say…stop the run!?
The Browns being able to stop the run is huge for this defense. I’m not sure that they can stop the pass yet but having half the equation is better than having none. I can’t remember the last time the Browns have been able to call playing the other side of the ball “defense”. In years past, “defense” has been a synonym for “the rape of the willing”. The addition of Williams and Rogers will allow the Browns to do something they haven’t tried in six years; put pressure on the QB. Stopping the run is a huge part to playing in the AFC North. But applying pressure to the QB is something that has to happen if the Browns want to be contenders for the AFC title. The addition of Williams and Rogers will allow for more blitzing packages that actually work because opposing offensive lines won’t be able to single block the Browns D-line anymore. This will create opportunities for the linebackers to find space to get to the QB.
Speaking of creating opportunities, Sean Jones is back this year. This guy is going to be the glue of the Browns’ secondary. Last year he had 96 tackles and 5 interceptions. Translation: Sean Jones is cracking receivers over the middle and forcing receivers to cut their routes short. He can single handily change the pace of the game with his hard sticks. Also he can provide some relief for Eric Wright who was burnt on 90% of the plays last year.
The Bad News Browns
Eric Wright is a bigger liability at the cornerback position than a 7/11 next to a crack house. The only difference is that Wright couldn’t rob a wide receiver let alone a 7/11. Last year he had 76 tackles which ranked him fifth overall amongst the Browns’ defenders. Anytime a team’s cornerback is ranked in the top five in the tackling category it means that the cornerback is not defending the pass but rather the yards after the reception. Stopping a wide receiver after the catch is the job of the safeties. Cornerbacks make sure the pass isn’t completed in the first place. Not to mention he had only one interception and forced zero fumbles. I know he was a rookie last year but that doesn’t mean he is going to be a great defender now that he isn’t a rookie.
Willie McGinest also worries me. If he was a horse, he would have been put down last year. I think he is getting a pass as the “proven veteran guy”. Too bad he hasn’t proven much in recent history. Hopefully Antwon Peek will take over the majority of the playing time after the week five bye. If not prepare for teams to take advantage of the flats.
I’m also going to toss in Brandon McDonald into “The Bad News Browns” category strictly based on experience. I feel like he isn’t as bad as Eric Wright but doesn’t have enough experience yet to be in “The Ifs, Ands, or Buts”. Basically he didn’t standout last year and probably won’t this year. And being as weak as the Browns are at the cornerback position means a lot more “Jesus Christ I have to make the f’n play again!” time for Sean Jones and Brodney Pool.
The Ifs, Ands, or Buts
I know earlier I was dry humping Shaun Rogers’ leg like a dog in heat but there are still a few question marks surrounding him. After seven seasons in the league and at age 29, one of two things happens to defensive linemen. Either they peak or they end up hosting late night talk shows on the NFL Network praying for CBS to finally fire Shannon Sharpe for speaking a mix of Klingon and gibberish. One thing for sure is that he isn’t going to have an average year. It is either going to be a success or a failure.
Brodney Pool is another “I don’t know what the F is going to happen” player. Last year he had 58 tackles and 2 INTs. The problem is that he doesn’t have the show of force like Sean Jones. And he has the tendency to take a few plays off here and there. But the upside is that this will be his second season as the fulltime starter. And even though he only had two picks last year, he had one for a TD and averaged 52 yards off those interceptions.
The biggest wild card for the Browns’ defense isn’t even a player. It is the new defensive coordinator Mel Tucker. Tucker was the defensive backs coach and co-defensive coordinator for Ohio State from 2001-2004. Bottom line, this guy knows how defensive should be played. When the Buckeyes won the National Championship in 2002, they had one hell of a defense; Donnie Nickey, Will Allen, Tim Anderson, Cie Grant, A.J. Hawk, Matt Wilhelm, Will Smith, Simon Fraser, Bobby Carpenter, Mike Doss and Chris Gamble (Dustin Fox was there just prove white people should never ever play cornerback).
The Browns on the other hand do not have one hell of a defense but do have the black version of Dustin Fox in Eric Wright. They also have a tough safety in Sean Jones, a tougher line than last year and a good set of linebackers. But what they don’t have, that the Buckeyes had, is speed and depth. So I don’t really know how Tucker is going to play the defense. But if he helped to establish the Buckeyes as a dominant defense, hopefully he can do the same with the Browns.
Special Teams
The Good News
Josh Cribbs, Josh Cribbs, Josh Cribbs and Josh Cribbs. I really think Cribbs was underrated last year solely based on everyone saying Devin Hester was the best kick/punt returner. Seriously, Chris Hansen couldn’t catch Cribbs. But whenever the question, “Who’s better Hester or Cribbs” was asked on FOX, Terry Bradshaw would throw up his arms, shake his head vigorously like he was Hulk Hogan “Hulking Up” to get out of a sleeper hold and scream “Who’s better! How bout who in the NFL is not better than Hester or Cribbs! I’ll tell you what I do know! Howie over here couldn’t tackle either one!” three seconds of fake laughs, followed up by dead silence and Bradshaw putting on his serious face, “Joshua Cribbs is a great young talent but Devin Hester is simply unbelievable. The things he does out on the football field…no one in the NFL can imitate. He’s a special, special, kid.”
But the numbers don’t lie and Josh Cribbs was clearly better than Hester:
| Kickoff/Punt | Yds | Avg | 20+ | 40+ | TD/Fum |
| Cribbs | 2,214 | 22.1 | 55 | 9 | 3/4 |
| Hester | 1,585 | 18.6 | 30 | 6 | 6/7 |
So F Terry Bradshaw, F Howie Long, F Jimmy Johnson, Frank Caliendo—you’re cool, and F Devin Hester…Josh Cribbs is the best kickoff/punter in the NFL and will prove it again this year.
Another piece of good news for the Browns’ special teams is Phil Dawson. I think he proved last year that he was a clutch kicker and could nail the field goal with the game on the line (The Oakland game never happened much like The Godfather III never happened). There is one downside to Phil Dawson; he hasn’t utilized the ‘70s kicker power mustache. Phil Savage should restructure the remaining two years on his contract to include a “no shaving of the stache” clause.
The Bad News Browns
The punt coverage was pretty bad last year. They could make Ralphie May look like Cribbs. This really killed the Browns’ defense. They weren’t good to begin with and giving up field position like the coverage unit did, didn’t help the cause. Basically, punt coverage is the Browns’ Achilles heel and could screw them again this year. If the Browns can’t figure out how to cover punts, good teams like the Cowboys, Colts, Steelers and Titans are going to take advantage of them like R. Kelly at the Junior Prom.
Outlook
After studying the schedule more than I’ve ever studied for an exam, I don’t think it is as tough as people have been making it out to be. There are only four teams with the ability to contain the Browns’ offense; The Dallas Cowboys, Pittsburgh Steelers, Tennessee Titans and Indianapolis Colts. I thought the Cowboys secondary was overrated last year, but the addition of Pacman Jones and his ability to make it rain should toughen up that secondary. The Steelers always play tough against the Browns and for some reason the Browns can never figure out their defense. The Titans front four of Vanden Bosch, Brown, Haynesworth and Kearse will be the Browns’ O-line biggest test. Also Harper and Finnegan at the corners without a doubt will be contesting every pass play. The Colts are just a little better at the corners compared to the Titans and have a better linebacker core. But every other team has a defense lesser than or equal to the Browns.
The Ravens just resigned Terrell Suggs but as we saw last year, their defense no longer has Dirk Diggler like stamina. The Bengals are currently filming a TV reality show spinoff of The Longest Yard from the Ohio State Penitentiary. The Giants looked good last year but like how Frank The Tank looked smart answering James Carville. The Redskins couldn’t stop Shaun Alexander and Matt Hasselbeck who were trading shocks on the deliberator to stay alive during the playoffs. The Jaguars never play well until week 10. The Broncos, Bills, Texans and Eagles are just plain awful on defense. Charles Manson has a better chance of getting paroled than any of those teams making defensive stands against the Browns.
The Browns’ defense shouldn’t get as abused as they did last year. They play seven games against teams that will cause problems for the Browns’ defense; The Dallas Cowboys, Cincinnati Bengals (2x), Houston Texans, Indianapolis Colts, and the Tennessee Titans. But I think the Browns’ offense will be able to bail them out against the Bengals and Texans. The Cowboys game will be a shootout. But I think the Colts are much better on both sides of the ball and it will take a miracle for the Browns to takeout the Colts. And if the Browns can stop the Titans running game and force Vince Young to throw the pass; the Browns could sneak out a win against them. So here is my prediction for the 2008 Cleveland Browns:
11-5
AFC North Champs
2nd round playoff loss against either the Titans or Colts